Views: 20,069,037 |
Home
| Forums
| Uploader
| Wiki
| Object databases
| IRC
Rules/FAQ | Memberlist | Calendar | Stats | Online users | Last posts | Search |
04-27-24 01:57 PM |
Guest: |
0 users reading Edge of the Universe Piece Selection Poll | 1 bot |
Main - Trash - Edge of the Universe Piece Selection Poll | Hide post layouts | Thread closed |
Which Musical Composition should be the music for Edge of the Universe? (Final Bowser Level) | |
mariogalaxythree's piece | |
Blaz's piece (Neutron Star Reactor) | |
Multiple voting is not allowed. Changing your vote is allowed. 12 users have voted so far. |
MK7tester |
| ||
Magikoopa I'm back Level: 104 Posts: 1422/3145 EXP: 11581427 Next: 280699 Since: 07-07-12 From: Dolphic Island Last post: 2600 days ago Last view: 2598 days ago |
Haha, nice saying Glem3, but all in all, I really hope NSR gets used in this galaxy. >.< |
MoreCowbell |
| ||
Member Mawile or riot Level: 73 Posts: 327/1420 EXP: 3457730 Next: 28138 Since: 11-20-12 Last post: 1662 days ago Last view: 1662 days ago |
I think NSR for final frontier.
Final frontier is more your classic bowser level Like mg3's piece, EotU is unusual and unexpected |
MK7tester |
| ||
Magikoopa I'm back Level: 104 Posts: 1423/3145 EXP: 11581427 Next: 280699 Since: 07-07-12 From: Dolphic Island Last post: 2600 days ago Last view: 2598 days ago |
Unusual and Unexpected is the exact opposite of the epic showdown in the |
Glem3 |
| ||
Retired staff Level: 39 Posts: 61/322 EXP: 379409 Next: 25362 Since: 07-07-12 Last post: 2904 days ago Last view: 2835 days ago |
Yes, it's unusual and unexpected in that it doesn't fit the pacing of a galaxy level and it's not very memorable for a final level theme.
I told MG3 when he asked if he could make this poll "I mean, I guess you can go for it but I'm not guaranteeing that I'll go with your piece just because others want to. Unless it's a really dramatic difference, maybe.". This isn't deciding whether or not it will be in the final level, like we've said before, this project isn't a democracy. I'm willing to let MG3 try to rework his piece and make it better than Blaz's. However, as it stands right now, it is most definitely not better than Blaz's. |
MK7tester |
| ||
Magikoopa I'm back Level: 104 Posts: 1424/3145 EXP: 11581427 Next: 280699 Since: 07-07-12 From: Dolphic Island Last post: 2600 days ago Last view: 2598 days ago |
Alright MG3, guess you'll have to take another chance. |
Glem3 |
| ||
Retired staff Level: 39 Posts: 62/322 EXP: 379409 Next: 25362 Since: 07-07-12 Last post: 2904 days ago Last view: 2835 days ago |
I also think another element here (and correct me if I'm wrong) is Blaz isn't actually active here so people don't really feel bad voting against his piece. But now I'm just ranting. |
mariogalaxythree |
| ||
Member Blarg. Yoshi. Of. Composing. Affected by 'RainBlarg' Syndrome Level: 110 Posts: 877/3627 EXP: 14058020 Next: 350866 Since: 12-24-12 Last post: 2267 days ago Last view: 2207 days ago |
Don't get the idea that I don't like NSR. I do, a lot. If Galaxy Reactor didn't exist, NSR would be better. NSR would work for EotU, but I just feel the very final theme can't be a copy of any sense. Take SMG2's final level theme. On it's own, NSR may be better than mine, but my track has more unique depth and atmosphere that would catch players off guard - in a good way. Keep in mind predictability, a good plot twist is better than the same formula. With my piece the player would think "Wow, that is quite different but interesting". With NSR "Its really good, but didnt I hear that before?"
EDIT: Its still too early in the poll. In a week or so, most (hopefully all) the main staff will have voted. Keep this in mind guys "The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few". ____________________
-MG3- IS HERE |
MK7tester |
| ||
Magikoopa I'm back Level: 104 Posts: 1425/3145 EXP: 11581427 Next: 280699 Since: 07-07-12 From: Dolphic Island Last post: 2600 days ago Last view: 2598 days ago |
We can't judge it by who did it, we have to judge it on the quality.
Like Glem, I find MG3's piece a skip-a-bye, it's good, but it doesn't have that "Final Epic Road to Bowser" pitch. IDK. |
MoreCowbell |
| ||
Member Mawile or riot Level: 73 Posts: 328/1420 EXP: 3457730 Next: 28138 Since: 11-20-12 Last post: 1662 days ago Last view: 1662 days ago |
Honestly, I was the one who "discovered" blaz, and when I heard NSR, I said where have I heard this?
If mg3 is right and EotU is a surprise, then I don't see why his piece shouldn't have a chance |
mariogalaxythree |
| ||
Member Blarg. Yoshi. Of. Composing. Affected by 'RainBlarg' Syndrome Level: 110 Posts: 878/3627 EXP: 14058020 Next: 350866 Since: 12-24-12 Last post: 2267 days ago Last view: 2207 days ago |
My point is, most gamers would listen to the music more if it was not what we've heard before. That is why Nintendo did something very different for SMG2's final level. |
MK7tester |
| ||
Magikoopa I'm back Level: 104 Posts: 1426/3145 EXP: 11581427 Next: 280699 Since: 07-07-12 From: Dolphic Island Last post: 2600 days ago Last view: 2598 days ago |
You guys, arguing with Glem3 won't do anything, i've tried it before and it won't work unless you out do his estimations. Also, he said it WON'T be a democracy, so the poll has no value at the moment. |
mariogalaxythree |
| ||
Member Blarg. Yoshi. Of. Composing. Affected by 'RainBlarg' Syndrome Level: 110 Posts: 880/3627 EXP: 14058020 Next: 350866 Since: 12-24-12 Last post: 2267 days ago Last view: 2207 days ago |
I'm just thinking about the general public here. It is our duty to entertain the gamers best as we can. And as many as we can. So doing something the people want instead of what I want (I could have made the song very different.) ____________________
-MG3- IS HERE |
shibboleet |
| ||
Fire Mario DROP TABLE users; Level: 123 Posts: 911/4661 EXP: 20895769 Next: 335497 Since: 07-07-12 Last post: 1351 days ago Last view: 364 days ago |
wait a minute, wait a minute.
Reany boi chipping in here. Glem3 JUST said that MG3's piece isn't good enough. Period. That's the answer, am I not correct? So, why don't we just stop voting for a piece, that's not even close to approved yet. Just wait, and let MG3 edit his, (Or just completely remake it) and see what happens then. Simple. ____________________ a |
Glem3 |
| ||
Retired staff Level: 39 Posts: 63/322 EXP: 379409 Next: 25362 Since: 07-07-12 Last post: 2904 days ago Last view: 2835 days ago |
No doubt, as it is right now, I would not put MG3's music in the final level. I find it incredibly silly, this "it's more important to be different than to be good". It hasn't just been on this board, either, it's been on nearly every world, something is good and then people say "but that would be too similar to _____". Stop it, the title of this hack is LITERALLY one of the least original things it could possibly be! This isn't Super Mario Galaxy 3. We're making a game in line with what Nintendo was setting up with SMG1 and 2. Sure, if MarioGalaxyThree's music was an amazing new theme that sounded great and like the final level of the game, same as Blaz's, and it was more original, right away I'd agree. But it's not.
MG3's theme, although it's good as a music track, doesn't fit with what the final level should sound like, nor does it fit what a typical SMG galaxy should sound like as well as Blaz's, nor does it fit with Mario's pacing, visuals, anything. I don't care how you want to try to stick it in, it doesn't fit, at least not here. A lot of you (me included) get a bit of a rush off of "This is so new!", but you can't let that get in the way of a better quality track. I'm fine with Blaz's piece being used for final frontier IF we get another track that's equally good but original. MG3, yours doesn't cut it for me, the instrumentation is off, the pacing is off, and it's not catchy enough. It's a GOOD track and it's well composed, but it doesn't FIT. If people made two designs for a galaxy, one being an awesome linear platforming level and the other a very well designed fetch quest, I wouldn't say "Well, that's NEW, we better slap it on in!". The platforming level would fit. It's the same case here, Blaz's music fits. |
Agent000 |
| ||
Member mah kitty Level: 74 Posts: 292/1426 EXP: 3535880 Next: 117664 Since: 07-07-12 Last post: 2321 days ago Last view: 886 days ago |
Gonna have to disagree on just about everything there. I don't like it just because its different, I like it because with some cleaning up it could be a very intense track for the conclusion of the game. If mg3 agrees i'll personally revamp it. ____________________ |AgentSplaturn| if someone uses an external hard disk to store porn on |AgentSplaturn| is it their sex drive? ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) |skyluigi| agent that's one of the best quotes I've ever seen on this IRC |
Glem3 |
| ||
Retired staff Level: 39 Posts: 67/322 EXP: 379409 Next: 25362 Since: 07-07-12 Last post: 2904 days ago Last view: 2835 days ago |
I don't know if either of you have shown instruments fitting for a final level thus far. |
Geometric Expulsion |
| ||
Member Normal user Level: 29 Posts: 47/168 EXP: 140006 Next: 7879 Since: 01-01-13 From: The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Island Last post: 3846 days ago Last view: 3697 days ago |
I completely agree with MrRean and glem. Mg3's definitely doesn't fit the last level as it stands right now, but nothing's been finalized yet, so there's no reason why he can't make it better.
EDIT: Ninja'd. Ah well, it was bound to happen eventually. |
Agent000 |
| ||
Member mah kitty Level: 74 Posts: 293/1426 EXP: 3535880 Next: 117664 Since: 07-07-12 Last post: 2321 days ago Last view: 886 days ago |
Posted by Glem3 I use the exact same soundset as Blaz. ____________________ |AgentSplaturn| if someone uses an external hard disk to store porn on |AgentSplaturn| is it their sex drive? ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) |skyluigi| agent that's one of the best quotes I've ever seen on this IRC |
Glem3 |
| ||
Retired staff Level: 39 Posts: 70/322 EXP: 379409 Next: 25362 Since: 07-07-12 Last post: 2904 days ago Last view: 2835 days ago |
Well I haven't heard your music in a while I guess. But the most recent stuff I've seen from you definitely didn't match Blaz's in terms of quality.
On another note, I'm taking a new stance: Neither is fit for the final level. The final level is dark and twisted. It needs to be better than both, as well as have a bit of a more dark and twisted feel. |
Agent000 |
| ||
Member mah kitty Level: 74 Posts: 294/1426 EXP: 3535880 Next: 117664 Since: 07-07-12 Last post: 2321 days ago Last view: 886 days ago |
Posted by Glem3 Fair enough I suppose...I'm still going to try to get mg3's eotu and revamp it. (Oh, and for future reference, I wouldn't recommend saying a composer's music lacks quality ) ____________________ |AgentSplaturn| if someone uses an external hard disk to store porn on |AgentSplaturn| is it their sex drive? ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) |skyluigi| agent that's one of the best quotes I've ever seen on this IRC |
Main - Trash - Edge of the Universe Piece Selection Poll | Hide post layouts | Thread closed |
Page rendered in 0.031 seconds. (2048KB of memory used) MySQL - queries: 31, rows: 238/238, time: 0.014 seconds. Acmlmboard 2.064 (2018-07-20) © 2005-2008 Acmlm, Xkeeper, blackhole89 et al. |