Kuribo64
Views: 24,259,717 Home | Forums | Uploader | Wiki | Object databases | IRC
Rules/FAQ | Memberlist | Calendar | Stats | Online users | Last posts | Search 		03-19-25 11:31 PM
Guest:

0 users reading Do you want a Super Mario Galaxy 3? | 1 bot

Main - Gaming - Do you want a Super Mario Galaxy 3? Hide post layouts | New reply

Pages: 1 2 3
Do you want a Super Mario Galaxy 3?
Yes
67.7% (21)
No
32.3% (10)
Multiple voting is not allowed. Changing your vote is allowed. 31 users have voted so far.

gridatttack
Posted on 06-04-14 09:37 PM Link | #42231

Giant Red Paratroopa
K64 RPG Overlord

Level: 74
avatar
Posts: 585/1416
EXP: 3615066
Next: 38478

Since: 08-11-12
From: El Salvador

Last post: 1401 days ago
Last view: 199 days ago
Posted by Stygmax
Posted by Krazyguy75
I find all the people going "The ideas already used up" amusing, given that we're a site based around the creation of 3D mario levels, and we're still coming up with new ideas.


This. Also, it's not a tired gimmick because there are infinite things that can be done with it. It was the best direction Nintendo could have taken with the series before they were all like "Oh, people like Tanooki Mario, this means that we just need to stop innovating because people like the old stuff".

I would more than welcome an SMG3. You know, as opposed to a SM3D3 or a NSMB3. Oh, and SMS2 will never happen for the same reasons listed above. Ninty thinks that it didn't sell as well.


Of course, one can up with new ideas, but they still use the same engine, which feels the same (like the NSMB series)

Eventually you get something that feels like an expansion pack :P

But of course, people will still like it (see: NSMB games)

____________________
[image] [image]

Krazyguy75
Posted on 06-04-14 10:11 PM Link | #42233
Normal user

Level: 23

Posts: 60/100
EXP: 63322
Next: 4401

Since: 03-28-14

Last post: 3557 days ago
Last view: 3275 days ago 		I guess it depends on whether you like expansion packs :)

I personally think that the plot of both Galaxy games was negligible, and just the galaxies were all I cared about, to the point where I just neglected peach and finished all of them.

Degolegodyl
Posted on 06-04-14 10:35 PM Link | #42236

Larry Koopa
/r/pcmasterrace

Level: 93
avatar
Posts: 1732/2397
EXP: 7857888
Next: 194922

Since: 12-09-12
From: Toronto, Canada

Last post: 2217 days ago
Last view: 2104 days ago
Posted by Krazyguy75
I guess it depends on whether you like expansion packs :)

I personally think that the plot of both Galaxy games was negligible, and just the galaxies were all I cared about, to the point where I just neglected peach and finished all of them.

same here, but i can't say that the sms plot is any better (please dont hate me for this, I dont want a debate, i'm just saying that if smg had a better story, all of you would already be rooting for smg no matter what)

gridatttack
Posted on 06-04-14 10:36 PM (rev. 3 of 06-04-14 10:38 PM) Link | #42237

Giant Red Paratroopa
K64 RPG Overlord

Level: 74
avatar
Posts: 586/1416
EXP: 3615066
Next: 38478

Since: 08-11-12
From: El Salvador

Last post: 1401 days ago
Last view: 199 days ago
Posted by Krazyguy75
I guess it depends on whether you like expansion packs :)

I personally think that the plot of both Galaxy games was negligible, and just the galaxies were all I cared about, to the point where I just neglected peach and finished all of them.


Yeah. It can work, like the NSMB games.

But then you have too many people whining that nintendo is doing more of the same and they want more new stuff.

I wouldn't mind another SMG3, but I would better like to nintendo to try and make something new/different.

Also lol, since when the story is important in a mario game? Im sure most people dont care about it. (because its the same; peach gets kidnapped, etc, etc etc.)

____________________
[image] [image]

Degolegodyl
Posted on 06-04-14 10:57 PM Link | #42238

Larry Koopa
/r/pcmasterrace

Level: 93
avatar
Posts: 1733/2397
EXP: 7857888
Next: 194922

Since: 12-09-12
From: Toronto, Canada

Last post: 2217 days ago
Last view: 2104 days ago
Posted by gridatttack
Also lol, since when the story is important in a mario game? Im sure most people dont care about it. (because its the same; peach gets kidnapped, etc, etc etc.)

Yeh, but still, having an actual story line would be something new and good

MercuryPenny
Posted on 06-05-14 01:24 AM Link | #42239
Normal user

Level: 54

Posts: 8/712
EXP: 1194474
Next: 39396

Since: 05-24-14
From: :mroF

Last post: 1463 days ago
Last view: 1463 days ago
> story in a video game
> new or good

lol

SMG3 wouldn't make much sense since Nintendo has at least some level of originality. I don't think they would want to revisit Sunshine either - and remaking SM64 was already done and when Nintendo remakes a game, say goodbye to any sequels.
smwc | youtube

Krazyguy75
Posted on 06-05-14 03:58 AM Link | #42240
Normal user

Level: 23

Posts: 62/100
EXP: 63322
Next: 4401

Since: 03-28-14

Last post: 3557 days ago
Last view: 3275 days ago
Posted by MercuryPenny
SMG3 wouldn't make much sense since Nintendo has at least some level of originality.


Wait.

We're talking about the same Nintendo here?

The one that rereleases a mario platformer every few years?

The one that owns pokemon?

gridatttack
Posted on 06-05-14 04:07 AM (rev. 2 of 06-05-14 04:08 AM) Link | #42241

Giant Red Paratroopa
K64 RPG Overlord

Level: 74
avatar
Posts: 587/1416
EXP: 3615066
Next: 38478

Since: 08-11-12
From: El Salvador

Last post: 1401 days ago
Last view: 199 days ago
Posted by Krazyguy75
Posted by MercuryPenny
SMG3 wouldn't make much sense since Nintendo has at least some level of originality.


Wait.

We're talking about the same Nintendo here?

The one that rereleases a mario platformer every few years?

The one that owns pokemon?


The originality on the mario platformer is on the level design, not the engine/concept :P

As for pokemon...idk, maybe the designs of the pokemons :P

____________________
[image] [image]

Arisotura
Posted on 06-05-14 01:33 PM Link | #42243

Star Mario
in this room you have a pile of apple pies

Level: 165
avatar
Posts: 2312/9055
EXP: 58712561
Next: 223120

Since: 07-03-12
From: in a box :D

Last post: 24 days ago
Last view: 1 day ago
Posted by MercuryPenny
SMG3 wouldn't make much sense since Nintendo has at least some level of originality.

*ahem* NSMB2 *ahem*


If Nintendo's gonna make SMG3, they better have original ideas.

____________________
NSMBHD - Kafuka - Jul
melonDS the most fruity DS emulator there is

zafkflzdasd

Rydia
Posted on 06-05-14 01:38 PM Link | #42245
Member
Banned for repeatedly trying to cause drama, and disregard of authority

Level: 49
avatar
Posts: 542/545
EXP: 866229
Next: 17654

Since: 07-10-12

Last post: 3898 days ago
Last view: 3898 days ago 		Two is enough. I would play a third, but that doesn't mean I like the idea. I'm more towards SMS2. I feel that F.L.U.D.D isn't recognized as much as it should be. They need another Super Mario Sunshine.

NeoBlitzX7
Posted on 06-21-14 10:29 AM (rev. 2 of 06-21-14 10:29 AM) Link | #42869
Normal user

Level: 25

Posts: 90/115
EXP: 79736
Next: 9884

Since: 10-08-13
From: Somewhere in Germany

Last post: 961 days ago
Last view: 844 days ago 		Well, SMG was a Mario revolution, SMG2 was even more fun. If Nintendo makes SMG3 that game would have potential to be the best mario game ever made. (But only if Nintendo improves several things, e.g. the world. I mean we are in SPACE! Why are the galaxies so limited?)

TheSpeedyMouse
Posted on 06-21-14 10:34 AM Link | #42870
Normal user

Level: 42
avatar
Posts: 107/403
EXP: 511747
Next: 9615

Since: 04-05-14

Last post: 2941 days ago
Last view: 1996 days ago
Posted by NeoBlitzX7
Well, SMG was a Mario revolution, SMG2 was even more fun. If Nintendo makes SMG3 that game would have potential to be the best mario game ever made. (But only if Nintendo improves several things, e.g. the world. I mean we are in SPACE! Why are the galaxies so limited?)

They need to include more things than just power ups.

NoSkinnedKoopa
Posted on 06-23-14 07:49 PM Link | #42987
Member
"The most intense fight a human will ever have is between the person they are and the person they are capable of becoming!" - Coach Jae

Level: 44
avatar
Posts: 380/421
EXP: 577460
Next: 33825

Since: 12-24-12
From: Super Hyrule Land

Last post: 3137 days ago
Last view: 2409 days ago 		New original 3D Mario (please nothing like the SM3D series), SMS2, or sequel to SM64. Everything else would disappoint.

TheSpeedyMouse
Posted on 06-23-14 07:54 PM (rev. 2 of 06-28-14 12:24 AM) Link | #42989
Normal user

Level: 42
avatar
Posts: 109/403
EXP: 511747
Next: 9615

Since: 04-05-14

Last post: 2941 days ago
Last view: 1996 days ago
Posted by NoSkinnedKoopa
New original 3D Mario (please nothing like the SM3D series), SMS2, or sequel to SM64. Everything else would disappoint.

I would rather like a SMG3 than a SM642, but Nintendo really needs to try something new. If there is gravity things in it, sure, but there needs to be something new, and not just new power ups/characters.

KoopaTroopaMan
Posted on 06-28-14 06:31 PM (rev. 2 of 06-28-14 06:33 PM) Link | #43220
Member
Normal user

Level: 68

Posts: 74/1217
EXP: 2688866
Next: 39934

Since: 03-26-14

Last post: 2994 days ago
Last view: 1714 days ago
Posted by TheSpeedyMouse
Posted by NoSkinnedKoopa
New original 3D Mario (please nothing like the SM3D series), SMS2, or sequel to SM64. Everything else would disappoint.

I would rather like a SMG3 than a SM642, but Nintendo really needs to try something new. If there is gravity things in it, sure, but there needs to be something new, and not just new power ups/characters.
But SMG2 was't very much similar to SMG1, but it have new powerups, enemies, bosses, characters and such. I don't think SMG3 will be soo different. But things must be similar and new from the SMG1 and 2. Maybe the Fire Bros. and the Koopalings will be in SMG3. But SMG are in the space, so I don't know if Nintendo want to have the classic Koopalings in different galaxies in the universe. It must be new bosses everywhere in all the many galaxies. It would be cool with new bosses, aliens in the universe! Bouldergiest is a really cool boss. And he was in SMG1! So SMG3 will have very cool bosses. And TheSpeedyMouse, will a new part of SM64 be called SM642? I think it would be SM65 :)

Fruit Smasher
Posted on 08-10-14 04:01 PM (rev. 2 of 08-10-14 04:02 PM) Link | #46345
Member
Normal user

Level: 43
avatar
Posts: 60/415
EXP: 528969
Next: 36077

Since: 07-01-14

Last post: 2698 days ago
Last view: 2261 days ago 		I would like a new Super Mario galaxy 3. just think of 3D world, and I've been hearing around that there where tons more of ideas for SM3DWorld. just imagine them putting them in a 3D gravity filled game. Just think of what happened with Super Mario galaxy 2.5. it got canceled, yes, but all those ideas could be added into the game ('cuz there where a lot :P) and just throw in some really good creative levels. there's more they can do with a new SMG and im down with it! :yum: :LOL: [image]

NintendoFan
Posted on 08-10-14 05:50 PM Link | #46365
Normal user

Level: 42
avatar
Posts: 3/403
EXP: 505245
Next: 16117

Since: 07-15-14

Last post: 2634 days ago
Last view: 2628 days ago 		I really don't know how I feel about a SMG3. I thought that The original and 2 were enough, and that it didn't need a third.

As for SMS2, that's up to Nintendo, since most people liked it and others didn't. Personally I liked it, so I guess i'd prefer a SMS2 over SMG3.

Also, since we have an editor for Galaxy, maybe someone can make a fan made SMG3? Just saying.

And SM642. http://www.mariowiki.com/Super_Mario_64_2 This page states that it was just a game for the failed 64DD and it was cancelled. But...

http://www.mariowiki.com/Super_Mario_128 ...This page states that it turned into a game for the Gamecube called Pikmin. So if you've played Pikmin, then in a way you've played what could have been SM642.

____________________
A nobody.

SquidEmpress
Posted on 08-10-14 06:08 PM (rev. 2 of 08-10-14 06:12 PM) Link | #46366
Faking your suicide is a terrible thing to do. Get out.

Level: 101
avatar
Posts: 2607/2912
EXP: 10460127
Next: 257548

Since: 01-30-13

Last post: 3526 days ago
Last view: 3525 days ago
While Super Mario Galaxy 2 is my favorote Mario game, I think a Super Mario Galaxy 3 would be milking/botching the Super Mario Galaxy series.

So, I want a Super Mario Sunshine 2.


Edit:
Posted by NintendoFan
Also, since we have an editor for Galaxy, maybe someone can make a fan made SMG3? Just saying.


Basically, that is SunakazeKun's Super Mario Galaxy 3.A. So yeah, Nintendo doesn't need to make a Super Mario Galaxy because it's all right here.

____________________
Super Mario LOLand

Thanks to kaj for helping to port my Acmlmboard 2.5 layout to Acmlmboard 2.064!


TheSpeedyMouse
Posted on 08-10-14 07:04 PM Link | #46380
Normal user

Level: 42
avatar
Posts: 167/403
EXP: 511747
Next: 9615

Since: 04-05-14

Last post: 2941 days ago
Last view: 1996 days ago
Posted by HolyRomanEmperor
Edit:
Posted by NintendoFan
Also, since we have an editor for Galaxy, maybe someone can make a fan made SMG3? Just saying.


Basically, that is SunakazeKun's Super Mario Galaxy 3.A. So yeah, Nintendo doesn't need to make a Super Mario Galaxy because it's all right here.
But his 3.A doesn't include any custom models from what I heard, just planets in the game.

SunakazeKun
Posted on 08-10-14 07:06 PM Link | #46381

Boss Bass
Normal user

Level: 76
avatar
Posts: 143/1551
EXP: 3829545
Next: 176515

Since: 06-15-14
From: Germany

Last post: 2614 days ago
Last view: 2587 days ago
Nope. Splitwirez is currently trying out his custom planets for SMG3.
We're also going to use planets from SMG1 and probably the old Rolling Halfpipe planets.


Youtube | Github | Neo Mario Galaxy | Super Mario Galaxy & Super Mario 3D Land Modding
Pages: 1 2 3

Main - Gaming - Do you want a Super Mario Galaxy 3? Hide post layouts | New reply

Page rendered in 0.067 seconds. (2048KB of memory used)
MySQL - queries: 33, rows: 241/241, time: 0.014 seconds.
 [powered by Acmlm] Acmlmboard 2.064 (2018-07-20)
© 2005-2008 Acmlm, Xkeeper, blackhole89 et al.