Rules/FAQ | Memberlist | Calendar | Stats | Online users | Last posts | Search
|
| ||
| Views: 24,291,006 |
Home
| Forums
| Uploader
| Wiki
| Object databases
| IRC
Rules/FAQ | Memberlist | Calendar | Stats | Online users | Last posts | Search |
03-28-25 07:21 AM |
| Guest: | ||
| 0 users reading Dispute over Green Stars: SMG2 Vs. SM3DW (Make a decision?) | 1 bot |
| Main - General Chat - Dispute over Green Stars: SMG2 Vs. SM3DW (Make a decision?) | Hide post layouts | New reply |
| Are the Green Stars 3DW the same as the Stars feature in the Galaxy series, should they be merged? | |
| #1 They're not the same. | |
| #2 They're the same, should be merged. | |
| #1, But they should be merged. | |
| Other (Post below) | |
| Multiple voting is not allowed. Changing your vote is allowed. 15 users have voted so far. | |
| SuperMario64DS |
| ||
|
Normal user Level: 27 Posts: 30/141 EXP: 111514 Next: 4645 Since: 02-03-13 Last post: 3002 days ago Last view: 2887 days ago |
As all of you probably know, I really love to argue. So with that, I found something interesting on the Mario Wiki:
http://www.mariowiki.com/Talk:Green_Power_Star#TPP:_Merge_with_Green_Star_.28Super_Mario_3D_World.29 The topic being debated: The Green Stars in Super Mario 3D World are separate from the Green Stars in Super Mario Galaxy 1/2. I've argued the fact with many good points (You can see them in the link above), but it seems bias (Possibly among other things, suddenly everyone agrees with the opposer) has recently caused the results to turn; they should not be merged. What's your overall opinion? Even if they weren't "the same", I believe they still should share an article. But in this case, they're more or less the same thing. If you happen to have an account there, feel free to choose a side. Discuss, if I'm absolutely wrong then I'd like to know. |
| mariogalaxythree |
| ||
|
Member Blarg. Yoshi. Of. Composing. Affected by 'RainBlarg' Syndrome Level: 111 Posts: 3441/3627 EXP: 14615023 Next: 253337 Since: 12-24-12 Last post: 2602 days ago Last view: 2542 days ago |
They obviously function differently. SM3DW's Green Stars are Star Coins, while SMG2's Green Stars are power stars. ____________________
-MG3- IS HERE |
| Degolegodyl |
| ||
 Larry Koopa /r/pcmasterrace Level: 93 Posts: 1502/2397 EXP: 7865181 Next: 187629 Since: 12-09-12 From: Toronto, Canada Last post: 2226 days ago Last view: 2112 days ago |
I dont own nor watched any videos about 3DW, and still voted  |
| MarioMaster720 |
| ||
|
Member Some fraud Number 6738 Embodiment of Space Level: 86 
Posts: 1638/2007 EXP: 6035906 Next: 106201 Since: 11-24-12 From: Rogaland, Norway Last post: 3237 days ago Last view: 3210 days ago |
Posted by mariogalaxythree Technically the same thing. There's 3 of them in most levels (and 1-2 in the smaller ones), they aren't needed for the story and unlock things later on. They also look the same. Almost no difference other than the fact that the level ends after you get one in SMG2. I fully agree that Green Stars act just like Star Coins, but when you think about it the SMG2 Green Stars were also just like Star Coins, except for the aforementioned fact as well as the fact that the SMG2 Green Stars only appear post-story. And even if their functions are different so what? They're still the same thing. As far as I know Mariowiki doesn't make seperate articles like Coin (SMB), Coin (SMB2) and Coin (NSMB2). Sure they act slightly different but they look the same, have the same names and both appear in 3D Games. IMO that's enough for them sharing the same article ____________________ Former SMG2.5 Advertiser and one-time Level Designer/Artist - So Apparently Norway is rich while Denmark and Sweden are happy. What they don't know is that our wealth gives us happiness as well  : https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BfA4EbJCEAAsJfG.png:large |
| SuperMario64DS |
| ||
|
Normal user Level: 27 Posts: 31/141 EXP: 111514 Next: 4645 Since: 02-03-13 Last post: 3002 days ago Last view: 2887 days ago |
Posted by MarioMaster720 That's actually a very good point! I was starting to doubt my side of the argument. Thanks for the input so far, hope to see more supporters. On the Mario Wiki, the voting is currently 5/8, with the side I'm supporting losing. Hoping to get more on board, no reason in cutting up articles. |
| MK7tester |
| ||
 Magikoopa I'm back Level: 105 
Posts: 2589/3145 EXP: 12022556 Next: 239704 Since: 07-07-12 From: Dolphic Island Last post: 2935 days ago Last view: 2933 days ago |
They are the same, the whole point they added them instead of Star Medals was to pay homage to SMG2. They even say that in one of the E3 interviews. |
| SuperMario64DS |
| ||
|
Normal user Level: 27 Posts: 32/141 EXP: 111514 Next: 4645 Since: 02-03-13 Last post: 3002 days ago Last view: 2887 days ago |
Posted by Silver Could you possibly refer me to that E3 interview? It would help my case. Also, I found this: http://www.mariowiki.com/Talk:Green_Power_Star#.27Iwata_Asks.27_mention_of_Green_Stars |
| MK7tester |
| ||
|
Magikoopa I'm back Level: 105
Posts: 2599/3145 EXP: 12022556 Next: 239704 Since: 07-07-12 From: Dolphic Island Last post: 2935 days ago Last view: 2933 days ago |
I cant find it anymore, sorry. |
| MK7tester |
| ||
|
Magikoopa I'm back Level: 105
Posts: 2693/3145 EXP: 12022556 Next: 239704 Since: 07-07-12 From: Dolphic Island Last post: 2935 days ago Last view: 2933 days ago |
Sorry for double post but looks like they are at it again, they now think the Captain Toad from SM3DW is a seperate character from the galaxy games, i'm losing hope in Mario Wiki and gaining hope in mynintendonews. |
| MarioMaster720 |
| ||
|
Member Some fraud Number 6738 Embodiment of Space Level: 86
Posts: 1669/2007 EXP: 6035906 Next: 106201 Since: 11-24-12 From: Rogaland, Norway Last post: 3237 days ago Last view: 3210 days ago |
Posted by Silver Mynintendonews is a crap site. Half the news posted are negative, the guy who runs it keeps trying to make Nintendo look bad and the comment section of each page is filled with trolls. I visit it mostly every day myself, but I still acknowledge the bad quality of the site. Also I was one of the people who started the Captain Toad argument on Mariowiki, due to how retarded it is for thhe wiki to NOT acknowledge they're the same (Some articles say they're the sMe, but other pages say he's different). But seriously, he looks the same, has the exact same voice, has the almost exact same name and has the exact same theme. How are they NOT the same (retarded wikia logic  )____________________ Former SMG2.5 Advertiser and one-time Level Designer/Artist - So Apparently Norway is rich while Denmark and Sweden are happy. What they don't know is that our wealth gives us happiness as well : https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BfA4EbJCEAAsJfG.png:large |
| MK7tester |
| ||
|
Magikoopa I'm back Level: 105
Posts: 2705/3145 EXP: 12022556 Next: 239704 Since: 07-07-12 From: Dolphic Island Last post: 2935 days ago Last view: 2933 days ago |
The posts are negative because Nintendo sucks right now. And don't get all fanboy on me.
But you are right that it is getting overrun by trolls. Okay then, GameXplain  |
| Dodecagon |
|
| Degolegodyl |
| ||
|
Larry Koopa /r/pcmasterrace Level: 93 Posts: 1565/2397 EXP: 7865181 Next: 187629 Since: 12-09-12 From: Toronto, Canada Last post: 2226 days ago Last view: 2112 days ago |
Posted by GrapeEscape Then why use Japan as an example? |
| Dodecagon |
|
| MK7tester |
| ||
|
Magikoopa I'm back Level: 105
Posts: 2706/3145 EXP: 12022556 Next: 239704 Since: 07-07-12 From: Dolphic Island Last post: 2935 days ago Last view: 2933 days ago |
Posted by GrapeEscape I NEVER SAID THE 3DS YOU GUYS, WHEN I SAY BAD, I MEAN WII U, I LOVE MY 3DS IIII LOOOVE MY 3DS, IT WAS A GOOD MOVE. Stop thinking 3DS when i say Nintendo is doing bad, please. |
| Dodecagon |
|
| D.a.r.e. |
| ||
|
Member Normal user Level: 16 Posts: 22/46 EXP: 19875 Next: 381 Since: 02-16-14 Last post: 4043 days ago Last view: 3997 days ago |
The way the stars are the same is that they are collectable. But the difference is that green stars in SMG2 appear toward the end of the game, and SM3DW green stars appear when you start the game. ____________________ Mom: You had a party while we were gone? We are concerned about your 91 year old babysitter! Friends: I didn't do it! Mom: You are grounded for the rest of your lives! Friends: FFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU Moral: NEVER have a party at your house. |
| MK7tester |
| ||
|
Magikoopa I'm back Level: 105
Posts: 2885/3145 EXP: 12022556 Next: 239704 Since: 07-07-12 From: Dolphic Island Last post: 2935 days ago Last view: 2933 days ago |
I think you are a bit too late, this thread was last replied to a year ago (literally ) |
| D.a.r.e. |
| ||
|
Member Normal user Level: 16 Posts: 24/46 EXP: 19875 Next: 381 Since: 02-16-14 Last post: 4043 days ago Last view: 3997 days ago |
The thread status was not old. And it wasn't a year ago. It was barely 2 months ago. The quick e-post window is still available. ____________________ Mom: You had a party while we were gone? We are concerned about your 91 year old babysitter! Friends: I didn't do it! Mom: You are grounded for the rest of your lives! Friends: FFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU Moral: NEVER have a party at your house. |
| Main - General Chat - Dispute over Green Stars: SMG2 Vs. SM3DW (Make a decision?) | Hide post layouts | New reply |
|
Page rendered in 0.077 seconds. (2048KB of memory used) MySQL - queries: 31, rows: 242/242, time: 0.028 seconds. ![[powered by Acmlm]](img/poweredbyacmlm.png "powering nostalgia")
Acmlmboard 2.064 (2018-07-20)© 2005-2008 Acmlm, Xkeeper, blackhole89 et al. |
