Kuribo64
Views: 19,856,545 Home | Forums | Uploader | Wiki | Object databases | IRC
Rules/FAQ | Memberlist | Calendar | Stats | Online users | Last posts | Search
03-29-24 12:28 PM
Guest:

0 users reading "Disposable" Galaxies - The ones we don't really really need | 1 bot

Main - SMG2.5 - General SMG2.5 talk - "Disposable" Galaxies - The ones we don't really really need Hide post layouts | New reply

Pages: 1 2 3 4
shibboleet
Posted on 08-27-13 08:35 PM Link | #31032
RHP is glitchy as hell. I'll have to say that. End of story.
(Also, even if we did get that working, it would still be blarg.)

____________________
a

Dodecagon
Posted on 08-27-13 08:44 PM Link | #31035
Fast Food has a lot of really neat ideas going for it. But it does seem too ambitious...I think it could still work, honestly.

MarioMaster720
Posted on 08-27-13 09:45 PM Link | #31051
Here are the galaxies which I would scrap and the ones I would definitely keep. The ones not listed are neutral, which means that I would like them to be included if they're done right, and not rushed or messed up.

Scrappable (IMO):

- Under-Over Galaxy (I dunno really why, but I've never been excited about this galaxy ever and thus want it scrapped because I know that something better could take its place).

- Still-Life Galaxy (Has a too similiar concept to Temporal Tumble and is in the same world, and I can't see any potential in Still-Life.)

- Dry Boneyard Galaxy (YES I SAID IT! Personally I do not see why we need 2 Ghost galaxies with similiar concepts and similiar names. I know that SMG2 also had 2 Ghost Galaxies, and I didn't really like either of those because of that. They should just have been merged).

- Flarefrost OR Aquaflame Galaxy (I say we either stick to tradition and use FlareFrost OR try and be fresh with AquaFlame. Maybe we could merge those galaxies? Maybe Star 1 of AquaFlameFrost could be focused on Ice, Star 2 on Fire and in Star 3 they merge so it becomes water)

The ones I really want us to keep unless something goes horribly wrong:

- Fast Food (Love the idea, and it has potential to be great, but I think people do not want it because we try and make it too complicated. I also fully agree with GrapeEscape)

- Toxic Terror (We really need a pure Poison Galaxy here IMO, and it also has lots of progress)

- Retro Remix (Self-explanitory)

- Ground Growth (It uses a underused SMG2 gimmick in a fresh way. We need more stuff like that!)

- Digital Circuit (...I dunno what to say I just really like the concept :3)

- Edge of the Universe (Self-Explanitory)

- Atomic Clock (is very fresh, has music done and a couple of designs. Is also an idea by Bowie and features SM64 Nostalgia)

- Humongous Fungus (for the same reasons as Atomic Clock, but it features SMS Nostalgia instead)

- Super Mario Galaxy (...)

So...those are my opinions :)




____________________
Former SMG2.5 Advertiser and one-time Level Designer/Artist


- FTKing Polari on DN using a mediocre deck: 100% DONE: https://i.imgur.com/TOyJiS0.png >:)
- FTKing Polari on DN yet AGAIN: 100% DONE: https://i.imgur.com/ZUTUPxw.png >8D
- Beat Polari using a deck that's so bad not even the biggest retard of retards would play it: https://i.imgur.com/RnnxkZt.png >:)
- So many Numbers....: https://i.imgur.com/c9KIqLH.jpg
- 5 Fusions in One Turn (epic OTK): https://i.imgur.com/ayP2PJ6.png
- IT ALL MAKES SENSE!: https://fbcdn-sphotos-b-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn1/t1/1522156_702674209772551_1751395151_n.jpg
- LOL: http://9gag.com/gag/a1AB2AP
- DRAW! MONSTER CARD!: https://i.imgur.com/8BcN9SE.png
- So Apparently Norway is rich while Denmark and Sweden are happy. What they don't know is that our wealth gives us happiness as well :D : https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BfA4EbJCEAAsJfG.png:large

Stygmax
Posted on 08-27-13 09:54 PM (rev. 2 of 08-27-13 09:55 PM) Link | #31054
Agent, I added Flarefrost to the main list. ;)
Status: It was really, really fun, guys - thanks for the ride!

NWPlayer123
Posted on 08-27-13 10:09 PM Link | #31063

Posted by MarioMaster720
Here are the galaxies which I would scrap and the ones I would definitely keep. The ones not listed are neutral, which means that I would like them to be included if they're done right, and not rushed or messed up.

Scrappable (IMO):

- Under-Over Galaxy (I dunno really why, but I've never been excited about this galaxy ever and thus want it scrapped because I know that something better could take its place).

- Still-Life Galaxy (Has a too similiar concept to Temporal Tumble and is in the same world, and I can't see any potential in Still-Life.)

- Dry Boneyard Galaxy (YES I SAID IT! Personally I do not see why we need 2 Ghost galaxies with similiar concepts and similiar names. I know that SMG2 also had 2 Ghost Galaxies, and I didn't really like either of those because of that. They should just have been merged).

- Flarefrost OR Aquaflame Galaxy (I say we either stick to tradition and use FlareFrost OR try and be fresh with AquaFlame. Maybe we could merge those galaxies? Maybe Star 1 of AquaFlameFrost could be focused on Ice, Star 2 on Fire and in Star 3 they merge so it becomes water)

The ones I really want us to keep unless something goes horribly wrong:

- Fast Food (Love the idea, and it has potential to be great, but I think people do not want it because we try and make it too complicated. I also fully agree with GrapeEscape)

- Toxic Terror (We really need a pure Poison Galaxy here IMO, and it also has lots of progress)

- Retro Remix (Self-explanitory)

- Ground Growth (It uses a underused SMG2 gimmick in a fresh way. We need more stuff like that!)

- Digital Circuit (...I dunno what to say I just really like the concept :3)

- Edge of the Universe (Self-Explanitory)

- Atomic Clock (is very fresh, has music done and a couple of designs. Is also an idea by Bowie and features SM64 Nostalgia)

- Humongous Fungus (for the same reasons as Atomic Clock, but it features SMS Nostalgia instead)

- Super Mario Galaxy (...)

So...those are my opinions :)


Dry Boneyard has a cool boss idea, but I'm sure I or polari can work it into ghostly somehow.
Same with Aquaflame, grid and my design isn't exactly solidified yet, we can easily combine ideas and make it longer. It needs length ANYWAYS :P
I agree with all the rest of it except I'm neutral on fast food, as long as you guys make it interesting I don't care if it's there. But I have no ideas for it.
Ermahgerd so much on my plate.

____________________
"I hate playing musical chats" ~ Quote of the month

SquidEmpress
Posted on 08-27-13 10:19 PM Link | #31065
I found designing the finalized galaxy concepts difficult since I work better and more creatively with concepts I made up. So if we ever scrap a galaxy I can definitely help with a new concept.

Fearsome Factory Galaxy is pretty much the concentrated version the "The Works", an old idea of mine. Remember that I once was going to design the scrapped level of my own creation, Oily Oasis Galaxy. The other two, Yoshi Yard Galaxy and Volt Jolt Galaxy, came from YouTube users' comments on BowieZ's SMG2 music (possibly on his two unfairly removed videos).

But case in short, I will be here if any galaxies are scrapped to help out with new ones.

____________________
Super Mario LOLand

Thanks to kaj for helping to port my Acmlmboard 2.5 layout to Acmlmboard 2.064!


Stygmax
Posted on 08-27-13 10:20 PM (rev. 2 of 08-27-13 10:21 PM) Link | #31066
Posted by HolyRomanEmperorTatan
I found designing the finalized galaxy concepts difficult since I work better and more creatively with concepts I made up. So if we ever scrap a galaxy I can definitely help with a new concept.

Fearsome Factory Galaxy is pretty much the concentrated version the "The Works", an old idea of mine. Remember that I once was going to design the scrapped level of my own creation, Oily Oasis Galaxy. The other two, Yoshi Yard Galaxy and Volt Jolt Galaxy, came from YouTube users' comments on BowieZ's SMG2 music (possibly on his two unfairly removed videos).

But case in short, I will be here if any galaxies are scrapped to help out with new ones.


We won't scrap old galaxies unless you've already fully designed the new idea.
Status: It was really, really fun, guys - thanks for the ride!

Dodecagon
Posted on 08-27-13 10:25 PM Link | #31067
What exactly do you mean by "fully designed", Stygmax? I'd like to make a galaxy of my own, but I can only pitch ideas. That's it, I can't make 3D models or draw a representation of what the galaxy would look like.

Stygmax
Posted on 08-28-13 12:19 AM Link | #31079
Posted by GrapeEscape
What exactly do you mean by "fully designed", Stygmax? I'd like to make a galaxy of my own, but I can only pitch ideas. That's it, I can't make 3D models or draw a representation of what the galaxy would look like.


Well, at least provide a text description of the level from start to finish. Visual representation would be good, but it's not required.
Status: It was really, really fun, guys - thanks for the ride!

MK7tester
Posted on 08-28-13 02:04 AM (rev. 2 of 08-28-13 02:04 AM) Link | #31108
My opinions

Fast Food - This is a good idea, why dispose it. .__. (Keep)

Misty Peaks - I don't think this one is bad, however I don't really see a lot of inspiration behind it. (Keep)

Under-Over - Boring (Dispose)

Rock 'n' Roll - It just sounds like a copy of Boulder Bowl (Dispose)

Rolling Halfpipe - I'm not really sure on this one, it's a cool idea but does it really not work? (Eh... Keep)

Still-Life - Blarg name, sounds boring. (Dispose)

Fortress of Illusion - Keep it if the mirror gimmick can be pulled off good. (Keep if conditions are well met)

Flarefrost - Freezeflame/Shiverburn redux... (Dispose)

mariogalaxythree
Posted on 08-28-13 02:10 AM Link | #31109
NO. Flarefrost does NOT NEED TO GO. Not only do I have themes approved for it, but there are still many ideas that can still be implemented into its design and make it EPIC.

____________________
-MG3- IS HERE


MK7tester
Posted on 08-28-13 02:15 AM Link | #31110
Umm, no, just because you composed tracks for it doesn't mean it's staying.

mariogalaxythree
Posted on 08-28-13 02:17 AM Link | #31111
Not only did I compose tracks, but still, the designs are pretty epic, even if they are incomplete. They are original and this galaxy really needs to stay.

____________________
-MG3- IS HERE


Agent000
Posted on 08-28-13 02:17 AM Link | #31112
If you have ideas for it that make it not just a copypaste of Freezeflame, I'd love to hear them. Otherwise, this is one of the galaxies I've been most critical of the whole time, because it's not remotely original.

____________________
[image]
[image]
|AgentSplaturn| if someone uses an external hard disk to store porn on
|AgentSplaturn| is it their sex drive? ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
|skyluigi| agent that's one of the best quotes I've ever seen on this IRC

MK7tester
Posted on 08-28-13 02:18 AM Link | #31113
This galaxy is everything but original.

mariogalaxythree
Posted on 08-28-13 02:18 AM Link | #31114
Fire/Ice mixed slide. Also having a fire and ice comet. Its just a small part of my existing design I made a while ago.

____________________
-MG3- IS HERE


MK7tester
Posted on 08-28-13 02:19 AM (rev. 2 of 08-28-13 02:19 AM) Link | #31115
You need to make music anyways, not designs.

And that alone does not make it not one of the worst ideas.

FnarGod
Posted on 08-28-13 02:20 AM Link | #31116
IMO though, We could replace it with something better :3

____________________
(layout nuked; unclosed style tag)

mariogalaxythree
Posted on 08-28-13 02:20 AM Link | #31117
maybe so, but can you at least keep it as a fire/ice mixup? The game NEEDS to have one and there are still so many untapped ideas waiting to be explored with the elemental mishmash theme.

____________________
-MG3- IS HERE


MK7tester
Posted on 08-28-13 02:21 AM (rev. 2 of 08-28-13 02:21 AM) Link | #31118
If we are gonna have a Fire/Ice mixup it better have something else in it. It was used in both damn games.
Pages: 1 2 3 4

Main - SMG2.5 - General SMG2.5 talk - "Disposable" Galaxies - The ones we don't really really need Hide post layouts | New reply

Page rendered in 0.076 seconds. (2048KB of memory used)
MySQL - queries: 30, rows: 236/236, time: 0.020 seconds.
[powered by Acmlm] Acmlmboard 2.064 (2018-07-20)
© 2005-2008 Acmlm, Xkeeper, blackhole89 et al.