Kuribo64
Views: 20,053,973 Home | Forums | Uploader | Wiki | Object databases | IRC
Rules/FAQ | Memberlist | Calendar | Stats | Online users | Last posts | Search 		04-25-24 11:16 PM
Guest:

0 users reading Super Mario Galaxy vs. Super Mario Galaxy 2 [SMG vs SMG2] | 1 bot

Main - Gaming - Super Mario Galaxy vs. Super Mario Galaxy 2 [SMG vs SMG2] Hide post layouts | Thread closed

Pages: 1 2
Which one did you like better?
The Original
69.6% (16)
The Sequel
30.4% (7)
Multiple voting is not allowed. Changing your vote is allowed. 23 users have voted so far.

Glem3
Posted on 02-14-13 06:56 AM Link | #15323
Retired staff

Level: 39
avatar
Posts: 162/322
EXP: 379338
Next: 25433

Since: 07-07-12

Last post: 2903 days ago
Last view: 2833 days ago 		I dunno. How can you think that a pancake with syrup on top is better than a plain pancake.

MK7tester
Posted on 02-14-13 07:01 AM Link | #15324

Magikoopa
I'm back

Level: 104
avatar
Posts: 1666/3145
EXP: 11579263
Next: 282863

Since: 07-07-12
From: Dolphic Island

Last post: 2598 days ago
Last view: 2596 days ago 		I got to admit you do have a point there, but what would syrup be like, WITHOUT THE PANCAKE? >=3

SquidEmpress
Posted on 02-14-13 09:25 PM Link | #15380
Faking your suicide is a terrible thing to do. Get out.

Level: 100
avatar
Posts: 391/2912
EXP: 10065520
Next: 288876

Since: 01-30-13

Last post: 3198 days ago
Last view: 3197 days ago
Syrup without pancakes is delicious. I am alreasy nostalgic about SMG2 since June 8, 2009. That is when I first found out about SMG2. Super Mario Galaxy 2 is feels better than the first because of that experience I remember and because of its great addition ans innovation. I truly believe SMG2 actually did break the mold. NSMB2 is the first Mario game in a long time to not break the mold. SMG2 is what helped SMG1 hacking also become possible. If you hate SMG2 (which no one has said here) then it is impossible to like SMG1.

____________________
Super Mario LOLand

Thanks to kaj for helping to port my Acmlmboard 2.5 layout to Acmlmboard 2.064!


Cirnya
Posted on 02-15-13 01:49 AM Link | #15429
Member
Normal user

Level: 30
avatar
Posts: 145/177
EXP: 150874
Next: 14995

Since: 01-28-13

Last post: 3952 days ago
Last view: 3952 days ago
Posted by MarioMaster720
Posted by Anthe
Sequels are never better than the original.


wtf? Paper Mario: TTYD and Pikmin 2 laugh at that comment.


Sorry, I actually liked the original paper mario more. Maybe it's just the graphic style, maybe it's just all the little things, but it just adds up to a better experience that TTYD does.

On-topic, I can't really decide which of the two is better, since they're both so good.

natnew
Posted on 02-20-13 01:55 AM (rev. 2 of 02-20-13 01:57 AM) Link | #16044

Bullet Bill
Normal user

Level: 47
avatar
Posts: 53/500
EXP: 720861
Next: 45342

Since: 12-07-12

Last post: 1908 days ago
Last view: 1810 days ago
It comes close... but I'd say SMG2.

Posted by Glem3
I dunno. How can you think that a pancake with syrup on top is better than a plain pancake.


it's more like... SMG1 was a pancake with eggs and sausage, SMG2 was a pancake with eggs and bacon... or something

____________________

[image][image][image]

mariogalaxythree
Posted on 06-13-13 12:40 PM Link | #25201
Member
Blarg. Yoshi. Of. Composing. Affected by 'RainBlarg' Syndrome

Level: 110
avatar
Posts: 2769/3627
EXP: 14055285
Next: 353601

Since: 12-24-12

Last post: 2265 days ago
Last view: 2205 days ago 		After seeing the disappointment known as 3D World, it made me go back and think about these 2 games. I used to think SMG2, but SMG2 was really the first 3D Mario game to be linear. Galaxy was a lot more open. After some thought, I change my vote to SMG1.

____________________
-MG3- IS HERE

SquidEmpress
Posted on 06-13-13 01:53 PM Link | #25296
Faking your suicide is a terrible thing to do. Get out.

Level: 100
avatar
Posts: 2091/2912
EXP: 10065520
Next: 288876

Since: 01-30-13

Last post: 3198 days ago
Last view: 3197 days ago
:c

SMG2 is still my favorite game and my vote still stands. Who knows, maybe the second 3D Mario will be open-ended like an SMS2 and it will top SMG2.

____________________
Super Mario LOLand

Thanks to kaj for helping to port my Acmlmboard 2.5 layout to Acmlmboard 2.064!


mariogalaxythree
Posted on 06-13-13 01:54 PM Link | #25298
Member
Blarg. Yoshi. Of. Composing. Affected by 'RainBlarg' Syndrome

Level: 110
avatar
Posts: 2820/3627
EXP: 14055285
Next: 353601

Since: 12-24-12

Last post: 2265 days ago
Last view: 2205 days ago 		Sometimes, a game can be incredible. But then you can also see that it paves the way for the downhill spiral for a franchise. Take Pokemon RSE for example.

____________________
-MG3- IS HERE

SquidEmpress
Posted on 06-13-13 02:11 PM Link | #25340
Faking your suicide is a terrible thing to do. Get out.

Level: 100
avatar
Posts: 2099/2912
EXP: 10065520
Next: 288876

Since: 01-30-13

Last post: 3198 days ago
Last view: 3197 days ago
Actually, I think the tech demo and reference game that Nintendo used when making SMG1, SM128, paved the way for linearity in 3D Mario games. Don't blame Da Game (SMG2) for it! I love SMG2!

____________________
Super Mario LOLand

Thanks to kaj for helping to port my Acmlmboard 2.5 layout to Acmlmboard 2.064!


mariogalaxythree
Posted on 06-13-13 02:14 PM Link | #25345
Member
Blarg. Yoshi. Of. Composing. Affected by 'RainBlarg' Syndrome

Level: 110
avatar
Posts: 2836/3627
EXP: 14055285
Next: 353601

Since: 12-24-12

Last post: 2265 days ago
Last view: 2205 days ago 		SM128? DOES NOT COMPUTE!!!

anyway, yeah. SMG2 did pave the way for the linearity of the newer 3D Mario games. It makes me doubtful that they will ever return to open world.

____________________
-MG3- IS HERE

ts142001
(post deleted) #27979

Degolegodyl
Posted on 07-14-13 03:31 AM (rev. 2 of 07-14-13 03:32 AM) Link | #27982

Larry Koopa
/r/pcmasterrace

Level: 92
avatar
Posts: 1147/2397
EXP: 7564983
Next: 191954

Since: 12-09-12
From: Toronto, Canada

Last post: 1889 days ago
Last view: 1776 days ago 		I did notice that. Smg1 was very open. But one felt that way because the main base (the observatory) and because of the comets, which were a lot.
Edit: i didnt notice this guy over me bumped a month old thread. But since its already bumped...

Arisotura
Posted on 07-14-13 05:19 PM Link | #27996

Star Mario
in this room you have a pile of apple pies

Level: 163
avatar
Posts: 1594/9020
EXP: 56272808
Next: 214836

Since: 07-03-12
From: in a box :D

Last post: 5 hours ago
Last view: 5 hours ago
This thread went far enough. Like most of the silly postcount++ polls made in this forum.

____________________
NSMBHD - Kafuka - Jul
melonDS the most fruity DS emulator there is

zafkflzdasd
Pages: 1 2

Main - Gaming - Super Mario Galaxy vs. Super Mario Galaxy 2 [SMG vs SMG2] Hide post layouts | Thread closed

Page rendered in 0.048 seconds. (2048KB of memory used)
MySQL - queries: 32, rows: 225/225, time: 0.019 seconds.
 [powered by Acmlm] Acmlmboard 2.064 (2018-07-20)
© 2005-2008 Acmlm, Xkeeper, blackhole89 et al.