Kuribo64
Views: 19,850,589 Home | Forums | Uploader | Wiki | Object databases | IRC
Rules/FAQ | Memberlist | Calendar | Stats | Online users | Last posts | Search
03-28-24 11:59 AM
Guest:

0 users reading "Disposable" Galaxies - The ones we don't really really need | 1 bot

Main - SMG2.5 - General SMG2.5 talk - "Disposable" Galaxies - The ones we don't really really need Hide post layouts | New reply

Pages: 1 2 3 4
Stygmax
Posted on 08-27-13 02:51 PM (rev. 3 of 08-28-13 02:05 PM) Link | #30970
Well, MG3 made a thread for Misty Peaks alone, but I had already secretly compiled a list of galaxies that I personally found redundant and unnecessary. Just to clarify; WE ARE KEEPING THESE GALAXIES UNLESS SOMEONE COMES UP WITH A BETTER IDEA FOR A LEVEL. THAN, WE CAN REPLACE THESE.

Each galaxy has a reason provided.

GALAXIES THAT SMG2.5 DOES NOT NEED:

1. Misty Peaks Galaxy. I'd vote for having another, smaller snow galaxy as this one just seems too ambitious and borders on the technically impossible. Our modelers have to sleep, people.

2. Under-Over Galaxy. Vague idea, no concept art or definitive designs. Nobody would miss it.

3. Rock 'n' Roll Galaxy. Bad, redundant design ideas with no real connection to each other. Neat idea, but not worth the effort of some of the proposed ideas.

4. Rolling Halfpipe Galaxy. Halfpipes are impossible. And one rolling ball galaxy is fine IMO, nobody is really clamoring for another other than for reasons like "IT'S AN SMG TRADITION".

5. Still-Life Galaxy. Polari suggested this. 'nuff said. It has no designs, art, or anything.

6. Bowser Jr's Tower of Illusion. There are some good ideas for Bowser/Bowser Jr. galaxies out there, and this is a waste of space. Not to mention we already have a galaxy using this gimmick.

7. Flarefrost Galaxy. It's basically a copy of Freezeflame and an unoriginal concept. Also, SMG2.5 already has a hot galaxy, a cold galaxy, and another hot and cold galaxy. MM720 also brought up that this galaxy could be merged with Aquaflame.

If you disagree with one of these, please explain why in helpful and constructive terms and I shall revise the list. If you have one to add, please provide a reason under the same terms.
Status: It was really, really fun, guys - thanks for the ride!

NWPlayer123
Posted on 08-27-13 02:53 PM (rev. 2 of 08-27-13 02:54 PM) Link | #30971
Personally, without rock n roll, the music notes won't be all that useful, and they should be :c

____________________
"I hate playing musical chats" ~ Quote of the month

Tahcryon
Posted on 08-27-13 02:54 PM Link | #30972
Rock 'n' Roll should stay, it's a unique concept which is also pretty interesting.

Me and NWP have been thinking about replacing RHP with a new Starball galaxy.


And I posted about a replacement for Fortress of Illusion already.


Also meh, I like Fast Food.



[11:57am] cosmological: we'll get to it
[11:57am] cosmological: when we get to a galaxy and can't think of anything we'll discuss replacing it



____________________


[04/15/2018]gridatttack: I still think the whole smg2.5 team are still in middle school lol
[04/15/2018]gridatttack: and they are 14yrs old
__________

cosmological: There's no one in Russia who doesn't agree with Putin, probably because his ideas are that great



mariogalaxythree
Posted on 08-27-13 02:56 PM Link | #30973
The problem is, we have the most progress with RHP, wouldn't it be a waste if we get rid of it? I mean we could use the models in a different galaxy...

If we are getting rid of RHP though, I suggest a city-like galaxy.

____________________
-MG3- IS HERE


NWPlayer123
Posted on 08-27-13 02:57 PM Link | #30974
Do you think we rejected the idea of a city multiple times for no reason? It doesn't fit :P
And like said, RHP is IMPOSSIBLE, we'd need to change the name anyways, so we may as well change the whole thing

____________________
"I hate playing musical chats" ~ Quote of the month

Stygmax
Posted on 08-27-13 02:57 PM (rev. 2 of 08-27-13 02:57 PM) Link | #30975

[11:57am] cosmological: we'll get to it
[11:57am] cosmological: when we get to a galaxy and can't think of anything we'll discuss replacing it



Which I clearly clarified in the beginning of the thread.
Status: It was really, really fun, guys - thanks for the ride!

mariogalaxythree
Posted on 08-27-13 02:59 PM Link | #30976
So, what are we going to do with the models then? I really don't want them to go to waste :/

____________________
-MG3- IS HERE


Tahcryon
Posted on 08-27-13 02:59 PM Link | #30977
Then find somewhere else they could fit, have fun.


They wouldn't fit anywhere else, they'll most likely die.

____________________


[04/15/2018]gridatttack: I still think the whole smg2.5 team are still in middle school lol
[04/15/2018]gridatttack: and they are 14yrs old
__________

cosmological: There's no one in Russia who doesn't agree with Putin, probably because his ideas are that great



FnarGod
Posted on 08-27-13 02:59 PM (rev. 2 of 08-27-13 03:00 PM) Link | #30978

Also, a reason RHP got alot of progress was because it was kinda easy with its low poly look to it :P

____________________
(layout nuked; unclosed style tag)

mariogalaxythree
Posted on 08-27-13 03:00 PM Link | #30979
Gah, this is what we DON'T want to do. We could possibly make RHP work if we add gravity. But the models are made and are good quality, so I really don't want them to go to waste.

____________________
-MG3- IS HERE


Stygmax
Posted on 08-27-13 03:02 PM Link | #30982
Posted by mariogalaxythree
Gah, this is what we DON'T want to do. We could possibly make RHP work if we add gravity. But the models are made and are good quality, so I really don't want them to go to waste.


I didn't want to either at first, but the fact remains that they are redundant. Halfpipes are impossible, the whole point of the galaxy is nil.
Status: It was really, really fun, guys - thanks for the ride!

FnarGod
Posted on 08-27-13 03:04 PM Link | #30985
I don't mind wasting it, it was easy to model dude. Its not even that shaded well tbh, we could just use it for a demo or something :P

____________________
(layout nuked; unclosed style tag)

mariogalaxythree
Posted on 08-27-13 03:04 PM Link | #30986
How are halfpipes impossible? With normal Physics, yeah, but if we position gravity correctly, it just might work.

____________________
-MG3- IS HERE


Tahcryon
Posted on 08-27-13 03:05 PM Link | #30987
Wouldn't it glitch out? o.o

____________________


[04/15/2018]gridatttack: I still think the whole smg2.5 team are still in middle school lol
[04/15/2018]gridatttack: and they are 14yrs old
__________

cosmological: There's no one in Russia who doesn't agree with Putin, probably because his ideas are that great



FnarGod
Posted on 08-27-13 03:08 PM Link | #30988
MG3 you dont know even how to make gravity ill bet, if they say it cant work. IT CANT WORK

____________________
(layout nuked; unclosed style tag)

NWPlayer123
Posted on 08-27-13 03:20 PM Link | #30989
The point of a halfpipe is NOT to cheat with gravity. Can skateboarders change gravity to get up a halfpipe? Hell no. The halfpipe was a halfpipe for a reason.

____________________
"I hate playing musical chats" ~ Quote of the month

Dodecagon
Posted on 08-27-13 06:57 PM Link | #31016
I personally don't feel like Still-Life galaxy's name and concept match that well. Judging by the name, I'd rather make this an art themed galaxy. A large twisting manor that requires you to find hidden switches and possibly use power-ups to progress through the halls. This should be more of a relaxing, puzzling galaxy, with little to no enemies. Various famous sculptures and paintings could cover the many rooms of the manor. But, if a majority of people are against that idea, I suppose that tweaking these sculptures and paintings to incorporate elements from the Mario games (characters, enemies, power-ups etc.) could work as well. As for the music? I was thinking a soothing, classical piano melody.

mariogalaxythree
Posted on 08-27-13 07:03 PM Link | #31017
I sorta agree. Still life kinda feels like one of those "filler" galaxies such as Flash Black. I know i have said this multiple times, but some type of city/future galaxy would make a great placeholder.

____________________
-MG3- IS HERE


Agent000
Posted on 08-27-13 08:19 PM Link | #31026
I'm uncertain about Mirror Madness because I'm still not clear on what is and isn't possible. Same for Fortress of Illusion.

As for Fast Food that was my idea so obviously I like it, but it's true there haven't been any good designs for it, so I'd be ok with replacing it if someone can think if a better Dash Pepper galaxy.

Also, my list of galaxies I'd like to see gone: Still-Life, Under-Over, and Flatefrost (aka the incredibly boring Freezeflame copypasta.)

____________________
[image]
[image]
|AgentSplaturn| if someone uses an external hard disk to store porn on
|AgentSplaturn| is it their sex drive? ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
|skyluigi| agent that's one of the best quotes I've ever seen on this IRC

Dodecagon
Posted on 08-27-13 08:34 PM Link | #31031
I personally think that Still-Life can be saved. Under-Over just seems too reminiscent of Flipsville, though. I could do without Flarefrost, too. I could do without yet another "hot/cold" galaxy.
Pages: 1 2 3 4

Main - SMG2.5 - General SMG2.5 talk - "Disposable" Galaxies - The ones we don't really really need Hide post layouts | New reply

Page rendered in 0.037 seconds. (2048KB of memory used)
MySQL - queries: 26, rows: 146/146, time: 0.012 seconds.
[powered by Acmlm] Acmlmboard 2.064 (2018-07-20)
© 2005-2008 Acmlm, Xkeeper, blackhole89 et al.