Kuribo64
Views: 19,854,947 Home | Forums | Uploader | Wiki | Object databases | IRC
Rules/FAQ | Memberlist | Calendar | Stats | Online users | Last posts | Search
03-29-24 07:38 AM
Guest:

0 users reading Super Mario Galaxy vs. Super Mario Galaxy 2 [SMG vs SMG2] | 1 bot

Main - Gaming - Super Mario Galaxy vs. Super Mario Galaxy 2 [SMG vs SMG2] Hide post layouts | Thread closed

Pages: 1 2
Which one did you like better?
The Original
69.6% (16)
The Sequel
30.4% (7)
Multiple voting is not allowed. Changing your vote is allowed. 23 users have voted so far.

MK7tester
Posted on 02-13-13 06:36 AM Link | #15182
While Super Mario Galaxy 2 is good, here's why I like the first one better:

-I liked the emphasis on actual space instead of daytime in SMG a lot better.

-I disliked the fact that SMG2 took alot of things away from the original galaxy. (Ray Surfing, Ice Mario, Fly Mario, Bubble Gimmicks, Mario's underwater spin actually being of some type of effectiveness)

-I disliked the fact that SMG2 had no bonus features like a Storybook or anything, although they were a little odd, they gave Super Mario Galaxy it's amazing story.

-I disliked the world map stuff instead of exploring a hub and venturing to different parts as the game went on.

--------------------------------------

But, I want to see your opinions!

MarioMaster720
Posted on 02-13-13 11:01 AM Link | #15186
SSL Y U NO VOTE? (your custom title fits you) :P

I like SMG1 better because of everything SSL said.

____________________
Former SMG2.5 Advertiser and one-time Level Designer/Artist


- FTKing Polari on DN using a mediocre deck: 100% DONE: https://i.imgur.com/TOyJiS0.png >:)
- FTKing Polari on DN yet AGAIN: 100% DONE: https://i.imgur.com/ZUTUPxw.png >8D
- Beat Polari using a deck that's so bad not even the biggest retard of retards would play it: https://i.imgur.com/RnnxkZt.png >:)
- So many Numbers....: https://i.imgur.com/c9KIqLH.jpg
- 5 Fusions in One Turn (epic OTK): https://i.imgur.com/ayP2PJ6.png
- IT ALL MAKES SENSE!: https://fbcdn-sphotos-b-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn1/t1/1522156_702674209772551_1751395151_n.jpg
- LOL: http://9gag.com/gag/a1AB2AP
- DRAW! MONSTER CARD!: https://i.imgur.com/8BcN9SE.png
- So Apparently Norway is rich while Denmark and Sweden are happy. What they don't know is that our wealth gives us happiness as well :D : https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BfA4EbJCEAAsJfG.png:large

Anthe
Posted on 02-13-13 11:02 AM Link | #15187
Sequels are never better than the original.

____________________
[image]

MarioMaster720
Posted on 02-13-13 11:44 AM (rev. 2 of 02-13-13 11:44 AM) Link | #15188
Posted by Anthe
Sequels are never better than the original.


wtf? Paper Mario: TTYD and Pikmin 2 laugh at that comment.

No seriously those 2 games really show what a true sequel should be. (It helps that Pikmin 1 and 2 were on the same console).
Both of those games fixed literally everything wrong with the original ones. EVERYTHING (The only thing Pikmin 2 could have had to make it better was to allow 4 players to play at once.)

____________________
Former SMG2.5 Advertiser and one-time Level Designer/Artist


- FTKing Polari on DN using a mediocre deck: 100% DONE: https://i.imgur.com/TOyJiS0.png >:)
- FTKing Polari on DN yet AGAIN: 100% DONE: https://i.imgur.com/ZUTUPxw.png >8D
- Beat Polari using a deck that's so bad not even the biggest retard of retards would play it: https://i.imgur.com/RnnxkZt.png >:)
- So many Numbers....: https://i.imgur.com/c9KIqLH.jpg
- 5 Fusions in One Turn (epic OTK): https://i.imgur.com/ayP2PJ6.png
- IT ALL MAKES SENSE!: https://fbcdn-sphotos-b-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn1/t1/1522156_702674209772551_1751395151_n.jpg
- LOL: http://9gag.com/gag/a1AB2AP
- DRAW! MONSTER CARD!: https://i.imgur.com/8BcN9SE.png
- So Apparently Norway is rich while Denmark and Sweden are happy. What they don't know is that our wealth gives us happiness as well :D : https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BfA4EbJCEAAsJfG.png:large

MoreCowbell
Posted on 02-13-13 11:53 AM Link | #15189
Hmm....
I actually replayed smg and am currently playing smg2

While I remember enjoying smg2 more at a first play, smg is definitely the best video game in existance (smg2 comes close)

Anthe
Posted on 02-13-13 12:00 PM Link | #15190
9/10 cases the sequel isn't better than the original.

____________________
[image]

Degolegodyl
Posted on 02-13-13 01:00 PM Link | #15193
While i really enjoyed smg1, i have to admit the world navigation is much easier to navigate in smg2.

gridatttack
Posted on 02-13-13 04:20 PM Link | #15197
I go with SMG1.
It was a nice experience playing the first game.

Its not that SMG2 is bad, its just since is almost the same as SMG1, it doesnt feel special like it did with SMG1, since SMG2 act like some sort of expansion or something like that...
But the visuals were better in SMG2 IMO.

____________________
[image] [image]

Tahcryon
Posted on 02-13-13 05:26 PM Link | #15199
I'm really torn ;~;

I guess I'll go with SMG1 because everybody else is too :P

____________________


[04/15/2018]gridatttack: I still think the whole smg2.5 team are still in middle school lol
[04/15/2018]gridatttack: and they are 14yrs old
__________

cosmological: There's no one in Russia who doesn't agree with Putin, probably because his ideas are that great



MK7tester
Posted on 02-14-13 12:58 AM Link | #15249
Posted by Polari
I'm really torn ;~;

I guess I'll go with SMG1 because everybody else is too :P


Don't vote for something just because everyone else does. ._o

Degolegodyl
Posted on 02-14-13 03:31 AM Link | #15285
Ikr, i actually enjoyed smg2 more, so i voted for smg2. I dont even care about the other votes

MoreCowbell
Posted on 02-14-13 03:32 AM Link | #15286
It really gets on my nerves when people vote based on other people

If you can't decide, then don't vote

Degolegodyl
Posted on 02-14-13 03:41 AM Link | #15290
Ikr. Just had to say that... Now i have to fill this post with words :/

SquidEmpress
Posted on 02-14-13 03:45 AM Link | #15293
I like both ganes, but I prefer SMG2. It had newer stuff in it despite the fact that it did not have things from the original such as bolts, Torpedo Teds, giant Pokeys, the red Pokey, etc.

____________________
Super Mario LOLand

Thanks to kaj for helping to port my Acmlmboard 2.5 layout to Acmlmboard 2.064!


Degolegodyl
Posted on 02-14-13 04:03 AM Link | #15307
I really enjoyed having yoshi, something people are forgetting.

SquidEmpress
Posted on 02-14-13 04:22 AM (rev. 2 of 02-14-13 04:22 AM) Link | #15310
Ah yes. SMG2 also had the splendid Spin Drill and ibviously, Diggas. You see? What makes SMG2 a bit better is the new and awesome features it introduced to the Galaxy gameplay style.

____________________
Super Mario LOLand

Thanks to kaj for helping to port my Acmlmboard 2.5 layout to Acmlmboard 2.064!


Degolegodyl
(post deleted) #15312

gridatttack
Posted on 02-14-13 05:24 AM Link | #15314
Even if SMG2 has more powerups, I say the first set that appears on SMG1 is better.
The ice flower was cool. The drill from SMG2 was meh, and the cloud flower was cool to.Yoshi was ok, but doesnt hurt in not having it...
But overall, I think the playset of SMG1 powerups were better (and the levels accompanying them too)

____________________
[image] [image]

Glem3
Posted on 02-14-13 06:27 AM Link | #15319
I'm... actually kind of surprised by this... 99% of places I go, people think SMG2 is better. Though it might be because most of us are young and since our lives have been shorter we're already nostalgic about SMG1 instead of 2.

MK7tester
Posted on 02-14-13 06:28 AM Link | #15320
How can you think a sequel is better then where it all started? :3
Pages: 1 2

Main - Gaming - Super Mario Galaxy vs. Super Mario Galaxy 2 [SMG vs SMG2] Hide post layouts | Thread closed

Page rendered in 0.070 seconds. (2048KB of memory used)
MySQL - queries: 30, rows: 237/237, time: 0.018 seconds.
[powered by Acmlm] Acmlmboard 2.064 (2018-07-20)
© 2005-2008 Acmlm, Xkeeper, blackhole89 et al.